We are proud to introduce Nicey Pie, all natural ice box pies made with some of your favorite Nicey Treat flavors. Crusts are made from scratch by our friends at 4 Birds Bakery. Our key lime pie with a graham cracker crust, and toasted coconut with a black seasame seed crust are now available ! Pick one up today at our Broad Ripple location and show everyone it’s possible to have your pie and eat it too! More flavors will be available soon. Order one online today. ORDER.